Now offering more legal services – Property, Commercial Law & Wills and Estate.

How Ministerial Direction 123 changes visa refusals or cancellations on character grounds

However, Ministerial Direction takes effect from 31 October 2026 and may affect visa applicants and visa holders facing character concerns.

The Ministerial Direction regarding Australia’s framework for determining visa refusal, cancellation and mandatory cancellation revocation matters is changing.

MD 123 was signed by Tony Burke.

Ministerial Direction 123 (MD 123) was issued for Home Affairs and Immigration and Citizenship.

Additionally, it commences on 31 October 2026, replacing MD 110.

The new Direction applies to decision-makers who are considering:

  • refusal or cancellation of a visa under section 501 of the Migration Act 1958; and
  • whether to revoke a mandatory visa cancellation under section 501CA.

MD 123 does not replace the character provisions in the Migration Act. Instead, it changes how delegates of the Minister and the Administrative Review Tribunal are directed to assess and weigh relevant considerations.

For people facing character-related immigration action, the changes could materially affect how their circumstances are presented and assessed.

Four primary considerations – not five

MD 123 reduces the number of primary considerations from five to four:

  1. Protection of the Australian community from criminal or other serious conduct
  2. Whether the conduct involved domestic or family violence
  3. Expectations of the Australian community
  4. The best interests of minor children in Australia, including child victims

The most notable change is that the strength, nature and duration of a person’s ties to Australia is no longer a primary consideration.

Ties to Australia – including long-term residence, family relationships and community connections – remain relevant, but are now classified as an “other consideration”. As a result, those ties will generally carry less weight relative to the four primary considerations.

For long-term residents facing cancellation, refusal or revocation proceedings, this change may be particularly significant.

Broader domestic and family violence provisions

Domestic or family violence remains a primary consideration, but MD 123 substantially expands the relevant definition.

The new Direction expressly captures conduct including:

  • image-based abuse;
  • stalking;
  • breaches of court orders; and
  • abuse occurring within caregiving relationships and cultural family groups.

Decision-makers must also consider the effect of domestic or family violence on victims and witnesses, particularly where a minor child is involved.

When assessing the best interests of children, the Direction separately addresses current and future risks of:

  • abusive conduct;
  • neglect;
  • exposure to domestic or family violence;
  • psychological abuse; and
  • economic abuse.

These changes broaden both the conduct and relationships that may be relevant to a character decision.

New focus on hatred and extremism

MD 123 provides guidance on the new character test ground in section 501(6)(baa).

The ground covers matters including:

  • membership of or association with a terrorist organisation;
  • association with a state sponsor of terrorism;
  • membership of or association with a prohibited hate group;
  • conduct constituting a hate crime; and
  • making, endorsing or encouraging certain hateful public statements.

The Direction also identifies hate speech, incitement of violence or discord, and related advocacy as conduct relevant to the expectations of the Australian community.

Applicants and visa holders should be aware that character assessments may extend beyond criminal convictions. Associations, public statements and other conduct may also attract scrutiny under the expanded framework.

A lower threshold for future conduct risks

One of the most consequential changes appears in Annex A of MD 123.

For certain character test grounds, the future-risk threshold changes from whether a person “would” or “will” engage in relevant conduct to whether they “might” do so.

Although the assessment must still be based on the individual circumstances and available evidence, the revised wording may allow decision-makers to act on a broader assessment of possible future risk.

Evidence addressing rehabilitation, insight, treatment, behavioural change and the person’s current circumstances may therefore become even more important.

Community expectations and migration compliance

MD 123 introduces a principle that the Australian community expects non-citizens to:

  • comply with Australia’s migration laws; and
  • depart Australia when their permission to remain has ended.

The Direction also recognises that most non-citizens comply with these obligations.

Community expectations may be considered even where a person could remain temporarily on another visa designed to facilitate their removal. A temporary immigration status will not, by itself, prevent this consideration from weighing against the person.

Criminal sentences and serious conduct

The sentence imposed by a court will now be relevant across all offence types. MD 123 removes the previous carve-out that excluded certain categories of offending from the sentence-weighting factor.

The new Direction also identifies the following as conduct to be viewed very seriously:

  • hate crime conduct; and
  • drug or property offences resulting in a sentence of five years or more.

A criminal sentence is not the only measure of seriousness. Decision-makers must still consider the nature of the conduct, its impact and the surrounding circumstances.

Business and employment impacts

The impact of a decision on Australian business interests is no longer listed as an “other consideration” that decision-makers must take into account.

Employment history and workplace contributions may still form part of the broader factual background, but MD 123 no longer expressly requires business or employment impacts to be weighed in the person’s favour.

What does MD 123 mean for visa applicants and visa holders?

The changes are particularly relevant to people whose matters involve:

  • criminal charges or convictions;
  • domestic or family violence allegations;
  • hate-related conduct, associations or public statements;
  • concerns about future conduct;
  • a notice of intention to consider visa cancellation;
  • visa refusal or cancellation under section 501;
  • mandatory cancellation; or
  • an application to revoke mandatory cancellation under section 501CA.

The movement of ties to Australia from a primary to an other consideration does not make those ties irrelevant. It does, however, mean that representations may need to explain more clearly how family relationships, residence history and community connections interact with the remaining primary considerations.

Character decisions are highly fact-specific. Outcomes may turn on the quality, relevance and organisation of the evidence provided to the decision-maker.

If MD 123 may affect a current or prospective visa matter, contact info@migrationaffairs.com.au or migrationaffairs.com.au/contact to discuss the next steps.


Speak with our immigration team: Book a consultation

Have more specific questions about your visa? Get in touch with Migration Affairs today.

Sign up to receive important news and insights straight to your inbox.